Saturday, May 8, 2021

COMAH of a Tank farm - Rhetorical Questions

Hi everyone, I would like to share some notes and questions regarding road tanker filling of a tank farm holding flammable liquids.

Some questions were made for the way large tanks are filled from tanker, as part of the Control of Major Accident Hazards (COMAH) Regulations.

Like my other posts, questions here can be asked for any generic process plants.

Please comment, like and subscribe.

Photograph 1: Liquid Storage Tank

Bund in a tank farm:

1.      Can you share the bund of a tanker offloading point with the same one from a tank farm?

(1)   Usually they are linked to a fire pit, that is brick lined

(2)   Where foam is poured inside of it (This is the American approach, not common in the UK)

(3)   Usually need bund and sump (for rain water)

(4)   Are the drains channelled into interceptor tanks?

(5)   Can sloping be used to remove pool under tank? – usual for butane tanks

(6)   Could you direct spills into another area, for burning, where fire engulfment is less?


Tank farm protection:

2.      Are the support legs of the tanks fire protected? – e.g. with Intumescent coating?

(1)   As the coating heats up, it swells, which chars and creates an insulating layer

(2)   This is ok against pool fires, BUT NOT for jet fires, as it blows off the char in

(3)   Usually the legs are over coated, (thin or thick)

(4)   But char on a thin film (structure) is soft & may not be able to handle, 37 kW/m2 of heat

(5)   Note that steel usually has a critical temperature of ~650 to 720°C

Photograph 2: Generic storage tank with pipes


Tanker filling transfer pump system:

3.      Is tanker being filled with own tanker pump or will it use the facility's pump system?

(1)   Usually design transfer system around the tanker

(2)   Tankers can have different pumps and systems – e.g. small or large pumps

(3)   Are the road tanker or tank rated for pressure, maximum of the transfer pump?

(4)   Have maloperations been accounted for? E.g. deadheading of pump?

(5)   Usually tanker have a compressor system with air for transfer rather than pumping.

(6)   Usually in COMAH sites, it is the sites in control of the pump and transferring, rather than the driver, e.g. pump, transfer hose coupling, connections, etc

Figure 1: Road Tanker Zoning (As per HSG176 guidelines)


Preventing tanker movement during filling:

4.      What are the safety systems to prevent tanker filling failures? E.g. tank movement during filling

(1)   Can the ramp (tanker inlet point) be wet? If in a slope for tanker to park on?

(2)   Has ice and snow been accounted for at the tanker filling point?

(3)   Battery powder interlocking to keys and brakes – to prevent movement of tanker

(4)   CCTV, with permanent staff – usually credited in a LOPA study

(5)   HSE guidelines usually has 3 types of tanker filling set ups,

                                          i.     Standard set up with little to no protection

                                         ii.     Mid range – 1 method in which the driver is protected

                                        iii.     Above average – multiple methods to protect tanker filling, e.g. movement detectors protection to trip transfer if road tanker is moved – HOWEVER this gives a lot of false positives

(6)   Types of protection

                                          i.     Wheel protection, to prevent drive away

                                         ii.     Battery interlocks

                                        iii.     Barriers

                                        iv.     Remove keys/cables

                                         v.     Break away couplings

                                        vi.     Automated trip valves

 

Photograph 3: Tanker Filling, connections

5.      Could short pneumatic coupling connections be used, to prevent tanker movement?

(1)   For example, a 1.5 metre hose, that could be stretched out, linked to trip system

(2)   Can it work for a manifold system, with multiple connections at distances away?

(3)   Would you need multiple specifications for these hoses for different types of tankers?

(4)   Where would it connect on the tanker? Rear or the centre?

(5)   Also account for different specs on the outlet on the vehicle

(6)   Would it require regular inspection?

(7)   Could the hose easily melt if it were ignited somehow?


Thank you for reading, please comment, like and subscribe to this blog

Hope you have enjoyed reading this

Chiraq


HAZOP of an Oil Water Separation Plant

 Hi everyone, I would like to share some notes and questions I made during a HAZOP (Hazard Operability) safety study for an oil water separa...